question

daza avatar image
daza asked

Octopus Now, open to all UK installs, no more MCS needed, competent persons

@Craig Chamberlain it’s now public mate. Octopus are shaking up the game no more MCS certificate needed. MCS already thrown their toys out of the pram and complaining that octopus have opened up the gateway. I imagine more companies are going to follow suit soon so guys and girls fill your boots get paid for what what you actually produce. I’ll be going the same way once I’m finished with my provider. Link below

https://youtube.com/watch?v=Kr4KODtHOKs&feature=shareb

mcs
2 comments
2 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

solar-sam avatar image solar-sam commented ·

As an Octopus customer with a self installed solar system without MCS cert, I've been talking to them about this. Its certainly not opening the doors to everyone. Its a trial, with a £250 price tag to participate, and I don't believe its even for solar, told it for car chargers and those with battery systems. Octopus make too much on solar referral payments to pre arranged MCS certified installers to want to give that up, Even though its not a legal requirement.

My system is fully MCS compatible, but I cant get a cert....even offering a decent payment for someone to view it and sign it off...So if you can help me and want some easy holiday money get in touch..can provide photos and video of everything, and not asking for any guarantees. Just a genuine MSC cert.

I've got full DNO approval for my system, it is time consuming as I went down the G98 first , then expanded to G99 as extra panels were added. My electrical drawing was just basic with pencil and ruler and took about 30 mins...must include fuse ratings, isolators, and G100 protection.

I'm still pushing Octopus currently, and have sent a letter to Greg which they suggest, but as I've not heard any reply expect thats another refusal. Next will be the official complaint as I'm claiming my system and installer is now MCS compatible as I'm just putting the finishing touches to an audit system, which was the only excuse Octopus could come up with for not granting me export payments (but can still send for free).

Think its going to be a long campaign.

1 Like 1 ·
matt1309 avatar image matt1309 commented ·

Finally!!!!


I like the line that MCS are taking, could lead to more dangerous installs.... Yet solar could always be installed by anyone just not export the excess for money without MCS....


Thank you Octopus! Fingers crossed the market follows.

0 Likes 0 ·
5 Answers
Craig Chamberlain avatar image
Craig Chamberlain answered ·

@daza well that all escalated rather rapidly didn't it! Haha!

Looking at the comments in the YouTube video you posted, mostly it seems that people are glad that the MCS cartel has been (perhaps) broken up. But I was also struck by comments from sparkies who have invested thousands of pounds in achieving MCS status only for that now to be undermined. I feel really bad for people caught in the middle.

But in the long term I think this is definitely a big step forward for renewables and ultimately the planet! It should remove some cost and friction from the move to adopt more renewable energy. I just hope that everyone respects this new opportunity for what it is and ensures that any installations that are applying for an export tariff are suitably well engineered and approved by DNOs etc. We can't afford to feed negative news headlines which might give the MCS folks traction to reverse this decision by Octopus.

But yeah, this is a fantastic outcome, if a little unexpected! :)

2 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

daza avatar image
daza answered ·

@Craig Chamberlain yes the bubble has burst but most sparks I know want to do it I’ve been telling my missis cousins they need to get into this side as well, they are doing commercial electrical work, all of this constant paying out as they got to keep paying to be accredited and then for every new edition reg book. This is a pay road block that has been lifted.

Unfortunately I think there will be some issues you look at house electrics and there is there we are all human and not infallible and also cowboys in every trade, MCS have just presented a course and people have past it, that doesn’t mean one when time constraints kick in they won’t lash it in or for more profit to get to the next job. But I too hope competent people do this and do a good job as the paywall isn’t just MCS it’s the companies that charge extra because MCS ie the course keeping it up to date they want payback on that investment. I think we are about to see the install as well as the installed material price go down to for a full install which hopefully would push up adoption.

I can see what octopus want to do it’s funny as that’s the same thing or similar thing Tesla want to do I’m not sure if it’s just there home batteries or maybe they set sights on vehicle to grid also.

2 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

dmsims avatar image
dmsims answered ·

I was flat out turned down by Octopus and pointed to a waiting list form...........

6 comments
2 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

Craig Chamberlain avatar image Craig Chamberlain commented ·

@dmsims do you mean you were turned down as a new customer, or as an existing customer seeking to obtain an export tariff? I'd guess you mean the former and as @Daza says, it could be due to a surge in new customers due to the relaxing of MCS requirements. Added to that the fact that for the last couple of years most customers have been discouraged from switching supplier due to the price cap so perhaps Octopus had fewer staff working in that area and are now having to redeploy staff to handle the influx.

2 Likes 2 ·
dmsims avatar image dmsims Craig Chamberlain commented ·
Yes existing customer. Got the MCS needed reply first. Then when I showed them the the updated T&C's got told to fill in the form
3 Likes 3 ·
daza avatar image daza dmsims commented ·
Guess all the other tentacles of Octopus haven’t been informed themselves or they are just so use to saying MCS that they are programmed. either way the change is happening and you are going to be in a better place may take a while but your on your way. @Craig Chamberlain i think this move is to Beat Tesla to the virtual grid. Just my assumption as Tesla just announced they want in on our energy market
0 Likes 0 ·
Craig Chamberlain avatar image Craig Chamberlain daza commented ·
Possibly, but tbh I think Octopus are just realising that the requirement for MCS is a nonsense given that, once DNO approval is received for an installation, you can legally export to the grid as much as you want within whatever export limit the DNO has set.


Any hand wringing from some parties about whether safety or quality is compromised etc is completely moot because neither Octopus nor MCS can stop someone exporting if they have DNO connection approval to do so. For example, my initial export meter reading for Octopus was something like 78kWh because I had already run some export tests before I got my SEG tariff set up.


The only question here is whether the generator gets paid for such exports and Octopus are savvy enough to realise that they can attract a bunch of new customers by being first to drop this pointless requirement.
4 Likes 4 ·
gazza avatar image gazza Craig Chamberlain commented ·
Totally agree!
1 Like 1 ·
daza avatar image daza commented ·

I imagine they are inundated with this announcement at the mo

0 Likes 0 ·
solar-sam avatar image
solar-sam answered ·

I'd love to see the MCS cartel broken up. Reviewed some large system quotes recently for a couple of friends as I've gat a trade account and can see and purchase wholesale. Hell of a lot of hidden mark ups, 5-6K profit in a 16k quote.

However I've also been informed that companies like Octopus get £500-£2000 per install for referral alone, then its "the best three in your area", not telling the customer the size of the pre-arranged backhander. Of course got to be MCS certified, which keeps the club running and stops decent electricians and builders from quoting.

Believe this practice without letting customers know smacks of the 1980's endowment scams, and we know what happened there.

All these extra costs bang the customers quotes right up, as a lot of hands to pay. Also goes against policy in my book of promoting green energy, as its keeping instal prices high.

In Australia right now can get a 6KW install for £1750, thats Perth region.

3 comments
2 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

Craig Chamberlain avatar image Craig Chamberlain commented ·
@solar sam yeah the "MCS certified" quotes I got originally were about double the cost of doing the work myself, and that was even with the VAT taken off. Of course, some of that difference is labour cost but given that the install was going onto a brand new trapezoidal steel roof where you just mount Renusol Metasole brackets with self tapping screws rather than faffing about with slates or tiles, it was a very easy installation. I already had the necessary SWA cables in trenches as well.

But even if I had been interested in paying twice the price, the estimated installation date was about 9 months into the future whereas I could do it myself more or less immediately. Or at least as soon as I got G99 approval.

I'm quite sure that, if MCS was no longer a thing, then many more electricians would be able to participate in PV and Battery installations, and that would benefit everyone and of course the planet itself!

I hope that Octopus aren't backing away from what appeared to be a bold decision to sidestep MCS. I feel very lucky that I got in at exactly the right time but feel bad for those such as yourself, who have been campaigning for longer than me and are still being blocked by red tape. I sincerely hope that red tape is cut for you soon.

1 Like 1 ·
solar-sam avatar image solar-sam Craig Chamberlain commented ·
You are completely right Craig, In your and mine cases we have saved thousands, which has reduced the payback time in mine to about 4 years going on current yields and non payment for export. However I'm certainly not giving up, but now my letters are being ignored by Octopus now I've almost overcome all the hurdles.. guess they will try to raise the posts next. Must be some accredited installers out there who could do with some very nice holiday money to certify my install via video or something else. Easy money for an hr or less work. Not as if its easy to come by in current climate. Also in other countries MCS is not a requirement to my knowledge, just "rip off Britain". Just did a DIY quote for a mate for a 4kw system and its sub £1500 quid. Demonstrates the current profits being made by some especially as you say on easy installs like a strong tin workshop roof.
0 Likes 0 ·
Craig Chamberlain avatar image Craig Chamberlain solar-sam commented ·

Yeah my capital payback time is somewhere around 5 years and maybe sooner depending on how energy prices change in that period. That's probably half of what it would otherwise have been and I honestly think I have a better solution for my individual needs.

Getting MCS installers to sign off DIY projects is certainly problematic and to be honest I think it would be difficult for MCS installers to do this without leaving themselves open to losing their MCS status. That said, if the house of cards is looking like being torn down then maybe existing MCS installers might be more willing to take that risk to earn some extra cash before it all collapses. If it's a case of paying Octopus £250 to get on the trial or pay an installer £250 to sign off the installation then why not? In fact this would probably be the final nail in the coffin for MCS if the market was flooded with MCS certs although I suspect MCS might notice if a company doing say 20 certs a week suddenly started doing 100! :D

Speaking of prices, even the Trina Vertex S 425W Black White Mono PV panels I bought back in late May have dropped significantly in price and are just £127.68 inc VAT each now, down from £163.80 (both from midsummer wholesale). These are really nice panels by the way - highly recommended. My array is 6.8kW and would cost £2042 at this new price.

0 Likes 0 ·
solar-sam avatar image
solar-sam answered ·

Most of the quotes I've seen include labour costs of 1500 to 2000 per install, and most single roof installs take 2 days, not counting scaffolding or multi tower erecting. However when you delve in deeper into the quotes often see things like "switches and cables £400", plus inflated prices per panel. Those AC and DC isolators must have certainly gone up in price, and as for cabling, they must have it coming out of their ears because all customers are being charged similar. However thats just making the quote look right, as if they put in the truth... referral backhander...£2000, labour £800, MSC associated costs £1000 profit £4000 householders would soon start moaning especially when the extras and profit adds up more than the base equipment cost.

2 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 190.8 MiB each and 286.6 MiB total.

Related Resources

Additional resources still need to be added for this topic