EV Charger relay clicks on and off when car is at 100%

Hello fellow Victron people,

I seem to have en issue with my EV Charger. Whenever my wife’s Fiat 500e is done charging the contactor for the three phase lines intermittently activates and deactivates. See this movie: relay_clicking.mov

Strangely enough, this does not happen with my Tesla Model 3.

I found a similar thread on the old community forum, that states that this is a calibration issue. However, it is my understanding that the CP line calibration is now done automatically (the manual calibration button is gone at least). The EV Charger is running firmware v2.05.

Also, I have measured the CP signal with my oscilloscope and the Fiat 500e does it by the book. Nothing to put a finger on here. It is fully charged and not requesting charge, so the voltage of the duty cycle should be ~9V. That is as expected:

The yellow line is the CP signal and the purple is the contactor. Hence the relay activates, while the car is only applying enough resistance to pull the CP signal to 9V (which means connected, but no charge requested).

How can I solve this? The post from the old forum seems solved by help from a Victron staff member, so no obvious solution here.

can you install the latest firmware and then come back with some feedback?

Hi Lucian,

Thank you for replying :slight_smile: Embarrassingly, I totally missed that a new firmware was out.

I have installed that now, but unfortunately the charger does the same. I made a video as well as some readings from the oscilloscope:

Video: Relay_clicking_v2.07.mp4

Readings of the CP line and the contactor:

Zoomed in a bit:

I’m still pretty convinced that the car is doing what it should here, but I may be wrong. I do notice that the voltage is actually a bit lower than what I would have expected at 8.2V - 8.4V.

What are the threshold margins that the voltages can be off compared to the standard? And wouldn’t the auto calibration compensate for this?

Thank you!

you can enable the “keep the contactor active when charged”, that should do the trick

Unfortunately, leaving the contactor open just breaks my other car (Tesla Model 3). If I do this it reports an error and I cannot resume any charging.

This is from service mode:

While I was doing this test I noticed the charging station alerted my that a new firmware version was available (2.08), but I cannot find anything on it in the changelog document on Victron Professional (?). Nor does it seem to be publicly available yet.

Are the changes in 2.08 related to this problem?

So it seems that with the Victron EV charger, I have to choose (by means of “keep contactor open” setting) which car I want to have working.

My two cars will never be able to charge errorfree without me changing this setting every time…

As I have proven that the cars are signalling correctly on the CP line with the oscilloscope, I had hoped for a fix in firmware.

Now it seems I have to go with a different charger, which sucks as I really really like the integration into my ESS system :frowning:

@biggun_benny Let’s have a look at the charger when this is happening, can we do this next week?
I’m busy with an event this week, but next week , we can have a call and look at it

I’m having the same problem. Fiat 500e La Prima (42kwh) 2022. Firmware car is up to date. Tried a different charging cable, tried manually calibrating cp-line. Firmware EVCS is 2.08. Problem does NOT occur with other brand chargers. If the start/stop loop that occurs continues for a while, it trips the car in a way that a full system reset (disconnect 12v battery) is needed. The function “keep contactor closed after charging” prevents the loop, but it’s a workaround, not a solution. My guess is that the state detection voltages are either not according to spec, or too strict for real world application.

I have had a couple of talks with Lucian. He is very helpful. Last thing we ended up with was that maybe the ground connection in my house wasnt proper.

I had the electrician test it though and my ground is perfect. The issue even happened when I used the ground connection from my power company, but that didnt change anything.

Lucian said that he could see in the charger that the CP line once in a while was below 7V in one of the periods. This triggers the charger to start, which it should. But I also had my 100MHz oscilloscope on the CP line and there was no such low voltages.

I can only conclude that the Victron EV charger is extremely sensitive and starts charging instantly it see a period under 7V. Honestly, I think this would be easily fixed in firmware, and this is my recommendation for Victron.

All this said, the Fiats seems to function just on the edges of the CP line thtesholds and these two things cause this problem.

Both Fiat and Victron can fix this, but I think Victron are easier to persuade. Lets see if they look at these posts :slight_smile:

I’m seeing the same issue with a Zeekr 7X - just posted Contactor cycling rapidly when car fully charged .

I did search before posting but didn’t find anything when I searched “contactor” or “cycling” :confused:

I’m also not thrilled at the option to keep the contactor closed - I do get family visiting with Teslas who will use the same charger.