Another solution that comes to mind would be to connect one of the MPPT devices to the Agrofets input for the winter months, perhaps with a smart battery sense.
However, these are all solutions that require a certain amount of expertise in planning and installation. On the other hand, they are also very inexpensive.
This seems like a good idea. More work to install than an AC to DC Charger, but more efficient.
At the moment I have AC CHangeover switch to my shore AC-DC Engine Battery Charger, so during winter I move the changeover switch to the On board Inverter that is powered by Service battery,
Then I log in to VRM every 3 weeks and turn on the inverter remotely then the AC/DC Engine charger comes on and I leave it to run for 8 hours to maintain the engine batteries.
Its not ideal, your proposal here seems easier and more hands off. Which diode do you suggest for this?
It is only because I am not sure to be able to play with diodes or other type of equipments (I am not expert).
So If something unidirectional (from service to engine) is available on the market easy to install and compatible with my instalation it can be my choice.
Perhaps this solution as well who is cheaper.
There is so many solutions and I do not know wich one is better for me.
The topic of standby chargers is discussed here time and time again.
It is important that you are confident in your planning and installation skills and that you ultimately take responsibility for your work.
Otherwise, please ask a local specialist to do it for you !
My solution is based not only on one or more diodes for decoupling and voltage reduction, but also on a self-resetting PTC fuse that limits the current. This circuit is from the Schaudt EBL 99 and is often discussed in forums where you can also find the circuit diagram.
I use also the programmable output of the solar charge controller, which only switches on when the service battery is fully charged (in my case, lithium and not lead) and only provides a trickle charge of around 13V. The parts only cost a few cents; the postage is the most expensive part.
Your personal challenge is to achieve exactly the voltage you want for a trickle charge and to design it in such a way that it works in all operating conditions.
In both of your designs, for example, is the question open what happens when you run the engines.
I would install a summer/winter switch for this purpose if necessary.
However, in order to make such statements with certainty, one would need to be on site and be able to take measurements. Therefore, i kindly request that you consult a local specialist if you do not feel confident about doing the project yourself.
I ordered the diodes, PTC, relay with optocoupler, and veroboard.
I will put in serie the PTC and the diode between the Service Battery end one starter battery, and the same between service and the second battry.
Normaly on the two shunts I have on both starters batterys, I shoud see (when the voltage increase from the MPPTs) a charging curent to the starters batterys?
And during the period I use the engines I open that circuit with a relay.