Wiring unlimited DC grounding - contradiction

In chapter 7.7 of Wiring Unlimited there is an apparent contradiction between the text of the first paragraph and the accompanying diagram. See the highlighted sections in the image below:

The text appears to indicate that there should be no grounding of the MPPT DC negative, however the diagram clearly shows the MPPT DC negative tied to ground through the common battery negative.

Could we please have a definitive answer to clear up this apparent contradiction.

2 Likes

Hi Ken and welcome to the community, you are getting confused, look closely…

It’s saying not to ground the PV negative, not the MPPT DC negative
See here >> 4. Installation (victronenergy.com) 4.6. Electrical connections

2 Likes

PV and battery.
Two different things!

But most people dont’t ground the battery minus.

Th text states the following: “The PV negative input of the MPPT is not isolated from the negative output”, this leads me to believe there is a current path between PV input and MPPT output.

Then the diagram shows a direct MPPT to battery negative connection which is then grounded.

Hope that clears up the contradiction I see.

PV negative input is NOT isolated from negative output. Hence, PV negative = MPPT negative output.
MPPT negative output = Battery negative.
In the picture the battery negative is grounded, hence the PV negative will be grounded.

A contradiction, so the OP is right…

LE: Ken beat me to it… :smile:

1 Like

If you read the text along with the diagram you will see there is a connection between the PV, battery and ground, this is the source of my confusion.

Given that the battery is connected to ground you have one connection. The text states do not ground the solar panel array. If you also ground the solar array positive or negative then you will have 2 ground points at slightly different voltages so you will get ground currents. What the whole section is saying is only have one grounding point for the DC negative. In steel hulled boats for instance as this is talking off grid, you must avoid ground currents at risk of corrosion of the hull.

2 Likes

Hi if you have two ground connections you create a parallel path for normal current to flow, i.e. a ground loop (ground loops are bad news and often hard to find). But I understand why people get confused.
So what @pwfarnell says…

2 Likes

The text is about not grounding the POSITIVE or NEGATIVE of the PV array. This is not the case as indicated in the diagram.

Grounding of array, if you are referring to the array frame in your reference to “solar panel
array” is a separate discussion.

Yes and my reply applies to this, although it was not strictly stated, i have edited.

I am referring to the diagram as it is, there is a clear path from PV negative to ground which is contradicted in the text.

Have a read of this…
Grounding Basics 3 - Solar Panel Grounding.pdf (375.9 KB)

1 Like

I am afraid that you can not take a small extract out of context, read the whole section. It is not saying that the PV negative must not get to ground at some point in the system, but that it must not get to ground directly on its own. That whole section says to ground the negative at a single point.

There is nothing wrong with the diagram, it is your comprehension of the whole section.

4 Likes

The mppt frame is connected to ground. Not the actual pv and battery conductors.
There are little screws on the casing for it.
Same as the inverter itself.

Earth connection is not grounding.

2 Likes

What @lxonline says this is a very important point
People reading this must understand the difference.

Maybe I have not asked the question clearly enough and no I am not taking anything in isolation but these two sentences are explicit:

Do not ground the positive or negative of the PV array.
and
The PV negative input of the MPPT is not isolated from the negative output.

Then the diagram goes on to show based on the two sentences above, what amounts to a direct connection to the PV negative.

Edit: Deleted incorrect interpretation of text.

Thank you @pwfarnell That clears it up, ignore my previous post. :blush:

It is saying, do not ground Negative of the panels upstream of the MPPT when the grounding will occur after the MPPT at the battery terminals.

Maybe this very explicit sentence needs a litle clarification -

"Do not ground the positive or negative of the PV array. "

seems to imply no grounding whatsoever of the positive or negative PV outputs which is clearly contradicted in the diagram. The wording could be clarified for instance add that "Direct connection of PV positive or negative must not be done at the PV array.

I fully understand the issues of creating multiple paths to ground.

1 Like

Also to be clear that PV-IN negative is the same with the DC-OUT negative.

1 Like

Thanks Dave between you and @pwfarnell my confusion has been clarified.

2 Likes

You’re welcome.
It’s good too hear you understand and good luck with what ever project you undertake and remember we are all here to help. :+1:

1 Like