My Victron ESS in the Allgäu – 28.5 kWp PV, Sonnen system, Fronius and 128 kWh LiFePO₄ battery project
Hello everyone,
I’d like to introduce you to our fairly extensive PV and battery storage system in the Allgäu. The system has grown over many years and has been expanded and modified several times.
We plan, build and operate much of it ourselves. Our long-term goal is to make our energy supply as independent as possible from the public electricity grid.
We’re currently working on a major expansion of our storage capacity, and in particular on how different battery types, BMSs and protective devices can be safely combined.
1. Our Victron system
The heart of our power supply is a three-phase Victron ESS.
Installed components:
-
3 × Victron MultiPlus-II 48/5000/70-50 in a three-phase configuration
-
Victron Cerbo GX with GX Touch
-
Venus OS v3.63
-
Victron EM24 as grid meter
-
VRM remote monitoring
-
ESS with self-consumption optimisation and backup power function
-
DVCC currently disabled
We have a fourth MultiPlus-II as a spare. We may expand to six MultiPlus-IIs in the long term.
The system currently operates grid-connected, but can switch to island mode in the event of a power cut.
2. Photovoltaics and inverters
We operate around 28.5 kWp of photovoltaics in total, spread across roofs with different orientations.
South-facing array:
-
Approx. 10 kWp of photovoltaics
-
Sonnen system with its own battery storage
-
Originally a standalone storage system
East/west array:
-
Approx. 18.5 kWp of photovoltaics
-
2 × Fronius Symo 10.0-3-M, each with a rated AC output of 10 kW
-
One is the Light version; the other has an integrated Datamanager and network communication
The east/west array originally had Growatt inverters installed.
These have since been replaced by the two Fronius units.
Since switching to Fronius, the system has performed significantly better, particularly during power cuts and in island mode.
Coordinating PV generation with the Victron ESS is an important part of the system’s further development for us.
3. Heating and larger loads
In addition to the usual household and farm loads, we operate:
-
Two EV charging points
-
A buffer tank of approx. 3,000 litres
-
Electrical use of surplus PV power for hot water and heating support
-
Other loads around the farm and buildings
We try to make the best possible use of surplus PV power ourselves, rather than feeding it all into the public grid.
4. Existing battery storage – VW NMC
We currently operate three self-built battery storage systems made from reused VW traction battery modules.
They use Panasonic lithium cells with NMC chemistry (nickel manganese cobalt).
Each battery bank:
-
7 VW battery modules
-
Approx. 7.4 kWh capacity
-
Its own TinyBMS
-
Its own DC contactor
-
Its own main disconnect
-
Existing 100 A fuse
All three battery banks are connected in parallel to the shared 48 V DC distribution system.
The battery voltage has so far ranged from approximately 46 to 56 V.
Each bank can be disconnected independently of the others by its BMS.
We’d like to keep using these batteries, as they have been reliable so far and can still be put to good use.
5. New storage expansion – EVE MB56 LiFePO₄
We’re currently building a much larger battery storage system using EVE MB56 LiFePO₄ cells.
Specifications:
-
64 × EVE MB56
-
Rated capacity of 628 Ah per cell
-
Planned configuration: 16S4P
-
51.2 V nominal voltage
-
Approx. 128.6 kWh total nominal capacity
-
REC BMS for cell monitoring and battery protection
-
Planned communication with the Cerbo GX
Originally, we wanted to build four separate 16S battery banks, each with its own BMS.
After further consideration, we’ve changed the plan and currently favour one shared 16S4P battery with centralised BMS monitoring.
This should reduce the number of independent switching and monitoring systems.
The final configuration and protection system are still undergoing technical review. The new battery has therefore not yet been integrated into the existing ESS.
6. DC distribution and short-circuit protection
The main challenge is the shared DC distribution for the new LiFePO₄ storage system and the existing smaller NMC battery banks.
To this end, we’re planning suitably rated copper busbars and separate protection for each battery connection.
We’re currently looking at:
-
ADLER EF3 DC fuses
-
Class T fuses
-
NH-gBat fuses
-
Victron Lynx Distributor or comparable DC distribution systems
For the large MB56 battery, we’re currently considering a main fuse rated at around 400 A. The final specification has not yet been decided.
The VW battery banks require correspondingly smaller fuses because of their lower permissible currents.
One particularly important issue is the possibility of short-circuit current being fed back from the other connected battery banks.
For example, if a short circuit occurs on a VW battery connection, the much larger MB56 battery could also supply a substantial fault current.
So our concerns are not limited to the rated current; in particular, we need to consider:
-
Adequate DC breaking capacity
-
Short-circuit current calculations
-
Selectivity and protection coordination
-
Cable and busbar protection
-
Safe disconnection of individual battery banks
We’d like to resolve these issues before the expansion is finally commissioned.
7. Different cell chemistries – NMC and LiFePO₄
Another important issue is the planned combined operation of different lithium cell chemistries.
Our VW batteries use NMC cells, while the new MB56 battery uses LiFePO₄ cells.
The two battery types have different voltage curves and potentially different permissible charging and discharging limits.
As they’re intended to operate on a shared DC busbar, we’re particularly concerned with the following questions:
-
What shared voltage limits are suitable for both battery types?
-
How will charging and discharging current be distributed between the battery banks?
-
How can the BMSs protect each bank independently while still working together effectively?
-
How can high equalisation currents be prevented when a disconnected battery bank is reconnected?
-
What additional control or protection hardware might be needed?
The ability to disconnect individual battery banks independently is already provided for.
However, we still need a suitable solution for safely reconnecting them with voltage monitoring.
8. REC BMS, TinyBMS, Cerbo GX and DVCC
Each of the three existing VW battery banks has its own TinyBMS.
The new MB56 battery is to be monitored by a REC BMS, ideally communicating directly with the Victron Cerbo GX.
DVCC has not yet been enabled in our ESS.
This raises a few general questions:
-
Can the REC BMS communicate its charge and discharge limits to the Victron system via DVCC while the VW battery banks continue to operate independently?
-
How does the ESS take the different limits of the individual battery banks into account?
-
What happens if one BMS disconnects its battery while the other batteries remain connected?
-
Would a higher-level controller or battery aggregator be useful or necessary?
We’ve already looked into solutions for combining multiple battery systems under Venus OS, but would prefer to use a reliable and transparent configuration.
9. Overall SOC and monitoring
One key objective is to reliably determine the overall state of charge of our batteries.
We’d ideally like to see both the SOC of each individual battery bank and the system’s overall SOC in the Cerbo GX or VRM.
During an extended power cut in particular, it’s important for us to know how much energy is actually still available.
Among other things, we’re looking at:
-
Victron SmartShunts
-
Individual monitoring of the battery banks
-
Capacity-weighted aggregation of SOC values
-
Battery aggregator solutions under Venus OS
We’d like the SOC calculation to remain useful even if individual battery banks are disconnected or temporarily unavailable.
10. Our long-term goal – as much energy independence as possible
In the long term, we’d like to develop our existing system so that we’re as independent as possible from the public electricity grid.
That means not just having enough battery capacity for the night, but also being able to operate reliably in island mode for extended periods.
Our priorities include:
-
A safe power supply during grid outages
-
Continued operation of suitable PV inverters in an islanded grid
-
Using PV generation to charge the batteries
-
Controlling PV output when the batteries are fully charged
-
Sensible control of larger loads
-
Reliable monitoring of the available energy reserve
-
Safe coordination between the different battery systems
Switching from Growatt to Fronius has already significantly improved the system’s performance in island mode.
With the additional MB56 storage, we now mainly want to increase the available storage capacity and make the system more robust and independent in the long term.
Of course, energy supply in winter remains a particular challenge.
11. Experiences and suggestions welcome
I’m particularly interested in other Victron users’ experience with:
-
Larger self-built LiFePO₄ battery storage systems
-
Operating NMC and LiFePO₄ batteries together
-
Different BMSs on the same ESS
-
DVCC and battery aggregator solutions
-
ADLER EF3, Class T and NH-gBat in a 48 V DC system
-
Safe pre-charging and reconnection of individual battery connections
-
Larger AC-coupled PV systems in island mode
As some safety-related questions are still unresolved, I’d especially appreciate pointers to clear technical solutions, manufacturer documentation and practical experience.
I’ll add an updated system diagram and, if applicable, photos later.
Best wishes from the Allgäu
Franz





