Victron ESS: Legacy Compatibility Is Now Holding Back Innovation

Concerning ESS & being to slow due to communication delay or physical delays NOT true! I made a PID regulator in node red as test. What happens is that the current ESS regulator isn’t programmed to be predictive. When grid demand rises the compensation moment is to late aswell in the rising as as downhill curve. The regulator changed the gridsetpoint positive or negative (rather agressive to trigger the normal regulator). The result no more positive overshoot off the reference gridsetpoint set at -100W. Conclusion adapt the software to the speed off the current meters which is 200ms update (my impression is that the software still works at lower speed then the actual meters); regulate based on how fast the value rises (make the regulator predictive instead off regulating after the facts) result reducing the typical overshoot.

Hi,

A request for enhancement:

Make sure all (old and newer) applications running in MS Window also available in Linux native (AppImage), I want to be not longer dependent on MSFT to run my energy grid.

I’m currently running Wine with MS Window applications like the VE.Config app, would like to run it without Wine.

BRGDS Bertrand

sorry, i don´t get that all

what are your wishes /expectations?

We have 25kWp of PV, just one MP2-3000

Today we “harvested” about 125kWh from the sun, parts were used, parts were given to the net

From the net we took about 200 Wh

What kind of improvements should i look for? reduce these 200Wh?

Hi @bertrand,

I second your request for enhancement.

One of my windows machines ended up with a corrupted SSD in August last year. This was as a result of MSFT update Tuesdays. When searching the web it become evident that many end users were effected by similar issues.
I am currently busy migrating to linux on bare metal and Wine emulation.

Victron does have VictronConnect for Linux. It seems to function without any problems.

The Cerbo GX etc runs a minimalistic linux o/s.

For you info

I’m running the window VE.config application over Linux using Wine…

The only caveats you need to be aware of is to make sure the USB (VE.PORT) port is recognized by Wine as COMx port

There is lots of tuto in google explaining how to do it and it is easy.

The ask is to have VE.config in native Linux in the future :wink:

Today i read that Tennet, a major operator of the high voltage power grid in the Netherlands, has warned the Netherlands about increasing power outages.

Tennet has been warning the Dutch government for many many years, but the various governments do not look further than 4 years ahead, so hardly anything is being done about it.

It seems that Victron is also playing the waiting game, by bringing new (industrial) gear to the market very slowly… look at what the Chinese can bring to the market in a few years time.

To survive, Victron must invest heavily in technology with more engineers to quickly bring new professional/ industrial ess/ ups products to market aswell extend the line for the consumer market.

Victron is not a publicly traded company; it is a family owned company. So they can choose to be as big as they want. Larger companies bring larger headaches. And it’s an order of magnitude worse if you’re a publicly traded company. Yes, I would like to see Victron provide additional products, and it’s frustrating that we can’t get Victron quality in some product categories. I’m a small business owner and I know how big I want to be. I’m asked all the time about bringing in investors so we can grow very quickly. I don’t want to grow very quickly and I don’t want to grow to be a large size company. Perhaps the Vaders feel similarly. The Chinese are leaders in power electronics, photovoltaics, and battery storage and they have national government policy backing them up. Sure, they make a lot of crappy products, but at the high end they make excellent products. Victron could focus solely on the 80% percentile of off-grid systems and still do quite well for themselves. Victron’s secret sauce is software. You’ll be hard-pressed to find Chinese power electronics that have even mediocre software.

with some of your points, especially regarding Victron’s openness, VRM platform, and software flexibility.
However, in my opinion the market has changed significantly over the last few years. Companies like Huawei, Sungrow and Sigenergy are investing heavily in software, automation and AI-based energy management.
Sometimes I feel that part of the Victron community is still comparing today’s products with competitors from 10 years ago, while the industry has moved forward very quickly.
I still respect Victron and use their products myself, but I would like to see faster development in areas such as smarter ESS control, automation and user-friendly energy management.
Of course, this is just my personal opinion and I respect different views.

Lest you think I’m making excuses for Victron, we also sell Sigenergy for grid-interactive systems since Victron doesn’t support that in North America. Sigenergy software looks flashy and works fairly well, unless you don’t have an internet connection or their cloud services goes down. They provide no means to know the state of your system if you aren’t connected to their cloud. You have to run Home Assistant and a 3rd party integration to be able to do that. It’s a huge miss. Otherwise, it’s a fine product and customers love it. Especially the V2X module.

Exactly why my battery bay has so much blue.

With battery near 100% SOC, SmartSolar MPPT remains limited even when there is available load. When I switch a large load off/on, ESS recalculates and MPPT immediately ramps up. This looks like GX/ESS/DVCC control not updating the MPPT limit correctly.

There are some rules that you maintain the output at 70% as spare.

If the grid fluctuates you need leveling capabilities (ramp up or down) and keep always the worst case in sight, sudden loadshedding or power fluctuations of the renewables.

The Brownout in Spain was such a case. A big loadshedding nearby a PV farm led to an instability which propagated thru the national grid and let to many outages. But they again were online in 10h.

Think about a system that depends heavily on cloud service and internet and the last and newest gadgets.

When it comes to reliability, look for the sturdy things which last 30 Years+ (doesn´t count communications like mobile phones )