I would like to build a solar installation using two Victron 250/60-Tr MPPTs, each connected to a PV string with an open-circuit voltage of around 230 V maximum.
I understand that, to comply with the regulations, I need to use a CPI to detect and prevent damage in the event of an insulation fault on one or more conductors in the PV strings.
My problem is that I don’t know whether I should use:
2 CPIs (1 per MPPT), at the PV input of each MPPT
1 CPI (on just one MPPT), at the PV input of either MPPT
1 CPI on the battery/MPPT busbar
I’m asking because I saw that the CPI IL5881 specifies in its documentation: “In one voltage system only one insulation monitor can be used. This has to be observed when interconnecting two separate systems”. Since the two MPPTs do not have galvanic isolation, I think I may be in the situation described…
I also saw that the Victron MPPT RS450-100/200 solves the problem by integrating a CPI (and galvanic isolation), but it’s oversized for my installation.
Due to the negative being common between the battery and both PV inputs, i guess this is your only option. Also requires you to leave the battery, or the DC system as whole, isolated from ground. It needs to be an IT system
Good evening, thank you for your help. That also seems like the most logical option to me. However, when you specify that the batteries must be isolated from earth, are you referring to the live conductors and not the chassis? For example, for Pylontech US5000 batteries, the manual says that the battery system must be earthed. Should I follow this procedure?
Yes, both live conductors, 48V positive and negative need to be isolated from earth, but the housing of the battery needs to be connected to earth. Same for the inverter and MPPTs. This ensures that an internal fault to the housing actually has a path to ground. If you leave a housng unconnected, a fault could remain undetected.
If we declare it as SELV, then the enclosures must not be earthed, and at worst, a fault causing leakage onto the enclosure is not dangerous (we’re at 48 V). On the other hand, if we declare it as an IT system, the enclosures must be earthed, but in that case an insulation monitoring device must be added on the battery side.
Well, if the enclosures are earthed then it cant be a SELV system, thats correct. But, it cant be anyway due to the PV voltage. Theres no isolation between the 48VDC of the battery and the (lets assume) 200VDC of the PV. So that alone disqualifies it as SELV or PELV, since you are not staying below 120VDC in the DC system. You can still build an FELV by also earthing the negative pole, which many of us do. But then it comes down to how you (or the authorities) interpret the definition of an FELV system.
Apparently french authorities dont accept it as FELV. If i understand correctly their main reasoning is that there is isolation between primary and secondary (in the MP, between AC and DC) and the DC system can have up to 200V in this example. Both of these points speak against FELV. Regardless of the 48VDC. And since its not an ELV it must be low voltage, where it gets into the TN/IT discussion.
Many others see it a bit differently in that the DC system itself has a primary and secondary side, one being 200VDC the other 48VDC, so the 48V part can be FELV.
Or maybe the french dont see the 48V as functional in its definition, since in a 48V battery its actually the main voltage, not some secondary that is used for adjacent functions. Which the definition of FELV states.
In France, all voltages are treated in the same way, so a Victron system must have 3 protective devices: one on the AC side, one on the PV side and one on the battery DC side. AC side: when connected to the grid, the grid’s earthing arrangement applies; off-grid, it is TN-S.
PV side: with a Multi RS or an MPPT RS, we have an integrated IMD, so no other protection is needed, even if the voltage exceeds SELV. With the MPPT 150/xx and 250/xx, there is no IMD: if the voltage exceeds SELV, you must therefore add an IMD on the PV side.
Battery side: with a MultiPlus, a MultiPlus-II or a Multi RS, there is galvanic isolation between the battery and the AC section (or the DC bus for the Multi RS). As the battery is isolated, the earthing arrangement depends on the protection scheme selected:
if you choose IT, the earths must be connected to the batteries and you must add an IMD on the battery side;
if you choose SELV, the earths must not be connected and you do not need an IMD.
and indeed, on the DC bus with the small MPPT 150/xx and 250/xx units, if the voltage on the PV side exceeds 120 V, since there is no isolation, we cannot classify the battery side as SELV
All right, but when using small MPPTs such as the 250/xx, is the PV side the same as the battery side, since there’s no galvanic isolation in the MPPT? (which means there’s a single insulation monitoring device (IMD) for the batteries and PVs as a whole, on the DC busbar)