Reducing losses in a single-family home during off-grid operation

With a three-phase supply to a single-family home operating off-grid, using 3 MultiPlus-II units has the drawback that their no-load consumption adds up, since most of the time the household only uses a few hundred watts. On the other hand, appliances such as the cooker, dishwasher/washing machine/tumble dryer, and possibly the water heater, require considerably more power for a few hours a day.

So my idea was — assuming, of course, that there are no actual three-phase loads — to use a fourth MultiPlus to supply the base load on a single phase, and only switch on the other three MultiPlus units when the load exceeds, say, 3.5 kW. Up to that point, there would be no problem with overloading the neutral conductor either. The automatic transfer switch (ATS) in the diagram would then switch over to three phases, while the fourth MultiPlus could continue to provide support via its AC-IN, or even shut down completely. If the load drops again, the three MultiPlus units could be switched off again.

Example: 3 * MultiPlus 6k5 (28W no-load consumption) + 1* MultiPlus 5000 (18W no-load consumption)
I estimate that full output would be needed for about 3 hours a day.

3 MultiPlus units:
24h: 3 * MultiPlus 6k5 → 2.0 kWh

4 MultiPlus units:
3h: 3 * MultiPlus 6k5 → 0.25 kWh + 24h MultiPlus 5000 → 0.43 kWh → 0.68 kWh

That saves 1.3 kWh, or 475 kWh a year, so the fourth MultiPlus would pay for itself fairly quickly.

Could this work? And do you even need to switch the neutral conductor in the ATS?

You’d also have to take into account that the financial losses are considerably lower in summer. It only really hurts when the energy lost has to come from the grid.

I suspect the costs might pay for themselves after 10 years, even without factoring in labour, and as for the control system, you’ll have to live with compromises. If anything breaks, the calculation goes out the window. If you could fit one more module somewhere, you’d have offset that too.

Hi,

the problem with the transfer switch is that there always has to be a brief power cut, or you risk currents briefly becoming so high that the fuses trip or blow. The problem comes from the inductive loads and the fact that they store energy. When switching, it can happen that the positive half-cycle had a high voltage just before the switch, but the negative half-cycle is present afterwards. That can result in a voltage difference of more than 600 V. I’ve killed a few relays this way myself, and even the 35 A Neoz fuses have blown!

Unfortunately, most transfer circuits simply ignore this problem.

Of course, you can also achieve this by switching off one system first and only then switching on the other!

The simplest solution would probably be to connect everything that doesn’t need much current to a single Multi, and simply put the three-phase system in front of it. While that’s switched off, all the cables on the other phases will of course be dead too. So you may need to change the wiring in the house! Modern cookers also run on 220 V and could be used with a Multi.

If you don’t need three phases, the simplest solution would be to connect a large Multi and a small Multi in series, and put everything in the house on one phase!

Bye

If I value the 475 kWh at 30 cents, I could buy a MultiPlus with that money in four years. But of course, you’re right: in summer it doesn’t matter, while in winter it’s probably even more economical to switch the system off for a month or two. It’s really hard to estimate how much the shoulder seasons would contribute. Space for panels is limited (a terraced house with a flat roof), and of course there also needs to be enough battery capacity to get through the night.

And even in summer, it would really bother me if 300 watts were used overnight to meet a demand of just 200 watts; I actually want to save energy, not increase my consumption. A difficult trade-off, but definitely worth considering. Thanks for that.

chris

Okay, unfortunately I’d already suspected as much. But what about two MultiPlus units one after the other? The internal relay is also used when the second one is switched on, so wouldn’t you have the same problem, especially if you connect two three-phase groups in series?

Very low WAF :grinning_face: It would really have to happen automatically and without any significant interruption.

Yes, that would be the neatest solution from an installation point of view. But then I’d have the problem that the (old) house wiring would need to be changed. A new cable would have to be run to the cooker through the flat, and the old, already full sub-distribution boards don’t look to me as though they can handle much current on the neutral. That would also be expensive, making the overall economics questionable.

Best wishes, chris

I always approach these “calculations” from two sides: once with the optimistic figures and once with the pessimistic ones.

The pessimistic estimate would be 150 kWh from the grid. In addition to the Multi, you’d need a changeover switch, an extra fuse, the DC wiring and possibly another Lynx. Then there are the effects Dieter mentioned on appliances that might not like being switched on and off all the time.

The ideal solution would probably be one where, in a three-phase setup, you can switch off two devices and switch the loads to ACin for winter operation.

I reckon your OFFGRID setup is “only” because of the registration issue…

With an ONgrid system, a single MP II would probably have been enough for you… even that would get you almost 100% coverage during the “sunny half of the year”…

And I think your solar system is also a bit undersized… and power cuts just don’t happen that often…

hi,

when the Multis are connected in parallel, they synchronise before switching on.

if you don’t need the whole setup as a backup power system, the simplest solution would be 2 systems on one battery: one for summer and one for winter, with both connected only via AC-in.

then you can use a small Multi for the base load, e.g. an MP2 3000, and one or more MP2 5000s for higher loads. another option would be a combination of 1 x MP2 3000 and 2 x MP2 5000 as a 2-phase system. but then you’ll need 2 smart meters or a virtual smart meter with the phase sequence corrected as needed, so that 2 ESS systems can run. of course, they also need to be controlled together. then you can run one or both systems, depending on what you need.

a large system would also be possible; you could simply switch it off when there isn’t enough PV and the battery is being charged. in that case, though, it would have to be charged via MPPTs. then you could switch it on when you need to power larger loads.

there are lots of options, pick one!

bye