ESS connection of a Multiplus to the grid

I have a Multiplus ll set up as an ESS. The system is quite simple in practice. The system is domestic with grid connection, and a power meter fitted. Solar is direct AC grid connected to the Consumer unit through its own meter and external two pole breaker with an MCBO to the Consumer unit breaker, the Car charging pod has its own RCD and MCB fitted which is designed for the charge Pod. It is Connected to the Grid supply by an MCB in the consumer unit. The Garage has its own consumer unit, with RCD and MCBs, and is again grid connected through an MCB to the consumer unit breaker and hence the Grid. All of the house circuits are connected through MCBOs. The Multiplus consumer grid feed though (AC1) is not currently used, but any low power circuits would connected through MCBOs. Similarly the inverter circuit (AC2) has a small load circuit connected though an MCBO. The Multiplus is the only charging circuit for the significant 48V battery bank, but is not used for export of power to the grid - only to balance internal AC power use when within the AC inverter capacity. System is in the UK.

Now the big question - should the Multiplus Grid Connection line be connected though an MCBO or an MCB? This does not appear to be clearly defined. The Multiplus has sophisticated protection for L and N polarity and leakage internally. Best Practice is that any circuit should only have one RCD device in any line from the main 2 pole AC breaker Switch. So which is the correct connection route - do you MCBO, or MCB? This seems to be moot point.

What is an MCBO? Could they perhaps mean an RCBO, i.e. a residual current circuit breaker with overcurrent protection? Or maybe just an RCD, i.e. a residual current device.

You are correct, I was far too busy, and MCBO didn’t look right when i typed it

Although an excellent question, the answer is unfortunately: “…it depends”.
Mostly because rules and regulations between countries differs and sometimes there’s room for interpretation, certain protections are “recommended” not required. That’s why it depends…

Not aware of the requirements in the UK, let’s approach your question from an Electronic Physics perspective or simply decent circuit design in general. First you need to protect devices and cables against overcurrent and shortcircuits, second, depending on how much you care about a human life, you should protect the system against ground faults. The former is done with a MCB, the latter with a RCD or combined with a RCBO. So in general, connecting a device to a grid should have a MCB and RCD, now the real fun starts…

With an inverter device, like a Victron MultiPlus, that delivers power on its own (from the battery) things are getting a bit more complicated. You have a grid that delivers power and now there’s another device, your Victron Inverter, that’s also delivering power to the same circuit, in parallel to the grid (AC-IN) or serial (AC-OUT). You need to take that “extra” power (things like Power Assist) into account choosing your MCB’s and RCD’s. It’s comparable with the last decade of PV installations, where 35A grid connections get extended with 16A solar systems, now you have a switchboard that needs to allow a maximum of 51A (35+16) where it originally was designed for 40A (or so). You would be surprised how many “Professionally” installed PV systems with bad circuits are out there, it all goes well, until it doesn’t…

The next thing, where most residential setups fail, is selectivity. Because, when doing it right (see 2nd paragraph), you have a MCB & RCD combo in front of your inverter and next the MCB & RCD combo’s in your (existing) circuit board. Current selectivity for your MCB’s can easily be found in the provided tables from the manufacturer, or using a more quick & dirty ratio of 1.6 (ie. 40A → 25A → 16A → 10A). There are also different types of MCB’s (like Type B & C) with different characteristics. More advanced designs can have back-up or cascade like implementations based on manufacturer provided coordination tables, but that’s extremely rare in residential circuits.

Selectivity for your RCD’s are even more fun… Assuming everything more than 30mA is fatal for a human, end devices should be protected by a 30mA RCD (probably already covered in your main switchboard or perhaps wall socket in the UK). Selecting a RCD in front of your inverter should not only be selective by current (most of the times x3, so for 30mA => 90mA) but ALSO by time, this is different from selecting MCB’s. I’m not aware of 90mA RCD’s, there are some 100mA (=>90mA) out there, but more widely available RCD’s are 300mA (which also are => 90mA). So the only reasonable RCD in a standard residential setup , in front of your inverter, should be a 300mA Selective (current + time) RCD, be aware, these are expensive.

But again, this depends on rules and regulations in your specific region/country.

Although the different setups below will work perfectly from an electrical point of view, these are considered badly designed and/or unsafe residential electrical circuits in general:

  • No MCB or RCD in front of inverter
  • A 30mA RCD (inverter) in series with another 30mA RCD (switchboard)
  • A 300mA non-selective RCD (inverter) in series with an 30mA RCD (switchboard)

Regarding MCB selectivity, one can argue for weeks how practical (and required) it is to be fully selective. As long the implications are known and accepted, be creative. Do NOT play with ground faults, it kills you…

Victron is providing the inverter, any guidance how to connect this device to your local grid & switchboard would end up with >100.000’s of variables. That’s one reason why there’s a network of local Victron Professionals.

Thanks, As Physicist, that’s why I asked the question! Logic allows you to look at the issue from many different sides, and I appreciate that most of the alternatives work OK - BUT!

If you use an MCB in the immediate grid connection to the Multiplus, you are relying on the sophisticated line monitoring of the Multiplus to protect the Multiplus and subsequent circuits, but your over-current is protected by the MCB - if you get the input wrong, the Multiplus just shuts down and drops out its main relays. but this still leaves any leakage current on the earth line from other sources ‘live’, so protection of the other circuits is equally valid, since their RCD/RCBOs should be doing the job of taking the failed circuit off line - ergo no Live or Neutral connection to the ground line.

I haven’t found any detailed description of what the full range of internal protection of the Multiplus does, but from experience know that it does quite a lot.

This leaves failure of the wires themselves - well mice to have teeth and do like PVC. Logic would define that the only completely safe option is to have an RCD immediately on the grid input to the facility, and that any grid cable to a remote RCD would need to be armoured! - even within the building. Current standards are going along the line of the individual circuit RCBO route at the distribution box.

The question was to find the ‘correct’ route, and as I suspect, there is probably no real answer to that.

You will forgive me, but my HV training started with - ‘eeeh, well laad, if yer going to poke it, make sure ye av yer rubber boots on and that t’other hand’s behind yer back’ ! - not perfect, but at least you might still be alive after you’ve poked it - but you are probably on the other side of the room if you’ve got it wrong!