Balancing Lifepo4 battery - right settings for Blue Smart charger

Hi Community,

We need some advice for our out-of-balance Lifepo4 battery. Our solar system was not checked lately, then we realized when we looked at it, that it went up til even 14.62V (!) sometime during September month. But in general each day was way over than 14.2V. Usually it was around 14.33V.

Then we started to balance it to set the absorbtion voltage down to 13.8V, kept it there for 2 weeks (looked okay), then increased to 13.85V for a week (worked okay), then to 13.9V for few days, then to 13.95V (was still okay, both shunt and solar charger showed the same). Then when we tried to set is to 14V is suddenly went crazy and went up to 14.12V. Since it’s a Li-Time Battery, no Bluetooth, etc, we don’t know which cell went off but one of them for sure. So we switched today to a victron wall charger. But since it has not cell balancing option just the general charging option for Lithium battery, we need to use the customer settings. It would be nice to get a step by step guide from some experienced user what to change in the settings and how many days should it be like that. Since most of the time we are not able to check the system and/or leave it on 220V charger weeks, a.k.a keep an eye on it every day, it would be nice to know what options have to make the cells healthy again without checking it hourly, and overall balancing it in fairly short time, like in few days or so.

For now it’s set in custom settings, max 10A charging, 13.8V absorbtion voltage, 13.5V float voltage, 2 hours absorbtion time. Not sure this is correct though.

Thanks in advance for any useful answer.

From what I have read about them, (As I do not own one nor have I ever used that particular brand) you set a 0.2 c rate for the charger.
Charged voltage between 14.2v and 14.6

So if your battery is 100AH then set 20 A charge max. So your choice of 10a is good.

0.1 of a volt is not exactly crazy. If you were spiking over 15 it could be concluded that the BMS is tripping.
It is not clever enough to trip just one cell.

And if it was the voltage should drop voltage by at least 3v i.e. 10.5v

A Li-Time LFP would ideally be charged at 14.2 to 14.4 volts, with a maximum of 14.6 volts.

How did you arrive at the charging voltage you mentioned?

Some smart guy said that it’s not okay if a battery set to 14.2V absorption voltage but it reaches on daily basis 14.33V-14.35V and occasionally even 14.62V. He said because the BMS trips or something like that because one cell is not working properly. So he told us to drain it to 13.2V then slowly increase the absorbtion voltage back to 14.2V, means climbing back to 14.2V in 2 month or so (it was all along on victron solar charger) so we did what he said. All looked good, all along the shunt showed the same voltage as the solar charger. We started with 13.8V, then 13.85V, then 13.9V, 13.95V never jumped over the set voltage more than 0.01-0.02V. (Float voltage was all along 13.5V and absorption time 2 hours…it’s still is)

But when we set it yesterday to 14V it jumped up to 14.12V…we thought something is off, so - no better idea had - we plugged it into the blue smart wall charger, nice the wall charger not doing sudden spikes as the sun does.

But now I feel like an idiot…did we do something wrong? This smart friend wasn’t smart at all? If the absorption voltage is ‘allowed’ to reach 14.62V sometimes, then the battery has no issue at all and no any balancing needed?

yep, that’s the issue. had no problem at all then we were told it’s not okay to reach 14.62V if the set absorption voltage is 14.2V and we need to re-balance the battery. :person_shrugging: Then I opened this topic to find the right settings for the wall charger and - as I understand it now - there was no problem at all with the battery?

It’s a real shame the battery doesn’t have Bluetooth. I’m also wondering why you think there would be an imbalance.

The battery is best charged at the voltage specified by Li-Time for this battery, which is 14.2–14.4 volts.

Charging the battery at a much lower voltage could actually prevent the cells from balancing properly.

My advice is to set the charger to the voltage specified by the manufacturer.

To understand this, 14.62÷4 means if they are balanced, each cell is reaching 3.65v per cell, so yes that is considered to be on the high side.
But then why is the BMS not doing its job? If there was a real issue then it should have tripped.

What does the battery manual or side sticker show is the charged voltage?
What I think from reading and understanding from your post a bit about them is that they have very slow balancing so it is critical to slow charge them.

14.2v is a more reasonable voltage at 3.55v per cell. They put this figure on their datasheet.
A 0.2v on the plus minus on their datasheet is acceptable as well. So 14.4 this allows variations on meter etc.

It is possible there is a cell running away, maybe something in the battery has changed as a possible explanation. But it has not changed enough to cause a BMS protection event. It could be that the tlc is all it needs.is what you are doing now. But adjust the absorption voltage a bit batteries need to reach a certain level before the BMS balancing is triggered.

If the BMS is set to “Balance while charging”, it can cause problems.

By contrast, setting the BMS to balance from voltage x is better, since the balancers are active above voltage x and equalise the cells to the set voltage difference.

the battery reached randomly 14.62V (average was around 14.35V in the victron app history) and we were told that one of the cell is not working properly, therefore needs balancing. drain it to 13.2V then set to 13.8V absorption voltage to let the runaway cell to slowly balance itself with slowly climbing back to 14.2V. but to be honest we have no clue. beginners here.

it’s a Li-Time battery…the only ‘communication’ with the battery is the shunt. No Bluetooth, no option to do anything with the BMS.

As I mentioned earlier, make sure the charger is set to 14.4 volts.

The Li-Time battery is balanced at the end of the charging phase, and that should be at a voltage of 14.4 volts.

The voltage sometimes rising higher may also be due to a charger’s temperature compensation.

I wouldn’t worry too much about the battery, and if you’re really that concerned about it, it would certainly have been more useful to buy a battery with Bluetooth and the ability to monitor the individual cells.

Charge the battery at the recommended voltage and enjoy using it.

I agree with @VictRon54 . Very often, when looking at the charging history of a system I see a maximum voltage reached that is above the set absorption voltage. Its not big deal for this to happen occasionally and doesn’t indicate a major issue. Sometimes having all this information at our fingertips can be less help if we don’t know how to interpret it correctly.

If the battery is working fine otherwise I wouldn’t worry about any of this. At the worst your absorption settings were too high. Make sure your charge settings are correct and you are using a reliable, good quality controller. Set the absorption to 14.2-14.4 and float to 13.8 and go with it.